38 Comments

Hi Laura! I was intrigued by your review of Town of Babylon when you called the book "a contemporary queer novel about ordinary life". Any recommendations for more of these kinds of stories? I like gay, ordinary stories but always feel overwhelmed in sourcing them. There are so many queer stories!

Expand full comment

I love these kinds of books, too! A few I love that I think fall into that category: All This Could Be Different, Yerba Buena, Butter Honey Pig Bread, Real Life, God's Children Are Little Broken Things (short stories, and so deeply about ordinary life), Just By Looking at Him, Rainbow Milk. I hope that helps. Happy reading!

Expand full comment

Thank you so much, Laura! Appreciate these recommendations. I did read Just By Looking At Him... mixed bag for me. I've heard great things about All This Could Be Different and am happy it has your endorsement!!

Expand full comment

I just bought The Town of Babylon this weekend—it was on sale, and I knew I couldn't pass it up because I could hear you screaming in my head to buy it! :D I can't wait to do a deep dive into the challenge and plan out my list!

Expand full comment

This makes me so happy! I love that I was screaming in your head about Babylon, very accurate!

Expand full comment

Hi there! I'm super excited for this reading challenge and have had a lot of fun working on my reading list. The two books I'm probably most excited to read are The Jasmine Throne by Tasha Suri (a book over 500 pages/South Asian author) and Vespertine by Margaret Rogerson (a YA book without a central romance) because I've really enjoyed previous works by both authors. I'd love to hear if anyone has suggestions for the "Weird Queer" prompt–I'm considering Sarahland by Sam Cohen, but I'm trying to give myself a few options for each prompt.

Expand full comment

Yay, so glad you're excited about it! I do have a couple suggestions for Weird Queer (one of my fav genres):

Funny, optimistic speculative fiction with weird formatting (it's all told in a company's Slack channels) and a lot of surreal stuff happening: Several People are Typing by Calvin Kasulke.

Totally wild but also super smart and inventive and heartfelt and thought-provoking: Margaret and the Mystery of the Missing Body by Megan Milks.

Beautiful writing about motherhood and a story that is both magical and metaphorical: Chouette by Claire Oshetsky.

Hope that helps! There are some other good picks on Storygraph, too.

Expand full comment

Oh, thank you, I've been recommended Several People are Typing before but I didn't realize it was queer!

Expand full comment

Definitely queer!

Expand full comment

I have only a couple in focus for now to prevent myself from being overwhelmed. :) The first prompts to get my attention will be 4. An Intersex author: The Trans Space Octopus Congregation: Stories by Bogi Takács and The Good Arabs by Eli Tareq El Bechelany-Lynch which meets a few prompts including 13. Books with less than 100 ratings on Goodreads and 24. A book under 150 pages. After that I'll browse through prompts for books added that I own but haven't read yet.

Expand full comment

I support your strategy for avoiding overwhelm. :-) Really looking forward to hearing what you think of The Good Arabs! (I thought it was super interesting structurally, especially.)

Expand full comment

Ooh, I did want to ask--does anyone have ideas for the Black history book one? So far I've got Black on Both Sides: A Racial History of Trans Identity by C. Riley Snorton and Wayward Lives, Beautiful Experiments by Saidiya Hartman as the main contenders. These are both good and I'd be happy to read them, I was just surprised that I couldn't find more. Like, is there a book on Gladys Bentley or other queer folks of the Harlem Renaissance that I'm missing out on? Suggestions appreciated and welcomed for anything for this category.

Expand full comment

One book i loved last year was Black Diamond Queens, a history of Black women in rock music (as artists themselves as well as groupies, muses, and subjects). I wouldn't call it a queer book specifically, but queer women are part of this history so they're absolutely in there!

Expand full comment

I don't have any personal recs for this. (Is it possible I created this specific prompt because I'd like to find more queer Black history books? Yes.) This is one I saw someone added on SG that looks interesting: Bulldaggers, Pansies, and Chocolate Babies: Performance, Race, and Sexuality in the Harlem Renaissance by James F. Wilson. Maybe a bit academic, which isn't everyone's thing.

But also, please interpret the prompts however you want! If you want to read a historical fiction novel about Black queer characters, I think it totally counts.

Expand full comment

For Black Historical Fiction, I read Dead Dead Girls by Nekesa Afia a couple of years ago. It's a Harlem Renaissance murder mystery. It's a series and Harlem Sunset came out earlier this year.

Expand full comment

Hello all! This came at a perfect time for me. One of my reading plans for next year was to read more queer lit, so this is exactly what I needed.

My first couple planned reads are for the first prompt: (read a book in translation outside Europe) and no. 15 (read an essay collection). For the first one, I'm planning on reading The Way Spring Arrives and Other Stories: A Collection of Chinese Science Fiction and Fantasy in Translation from a Visionary Team of Female and Nonbinary Creators (whew, that's a title). I've been eyeing this one for awhile, so I'm happy to get to it.

For the essay collection, I'm planning on reading It Came From the Closet: Queer Reflections on Horror, edited by Joe Vallese. I am not a horror movie fan (too much a scaredy cat) but I enjoy horror novels, so I'm interested to see the way that other queer folks have responded to classic horror movies. Also Carmen Maria Machado is a contributor, so....that sealed it. :)

By the way, Laura, I really enjoyed your piece on Book Riot about horror as a genre--so much of it resonated with me, and I also took away some new additions to my tbr, so thanks!

I don't have much for suggestions, but I would suggest Darcie Little Badger for the SFF by an Indigenous author. I read Elatsoe and loved it, and I think I may pick up A Snake Falls to Earth for this challenge. Though Joshua Whitehead is one writer I haven't gotten to yet, so I may read him instead.

Also want to point out that if anyone is looking for recs, and is on The Storygraph, you can see what other people have added as well!

Expand full comment

I'm so glad to hear about all your plans! I am also hoping to read It Came From the Closet. And I'm glad that piece about horror resonated with you. I'm really looking forward to reading the collection and seeing how it keeps expanding my ideas about what horror is/can be. (And I agree anything Carmen Maria Machado contributes to is worth checking out!)

I can't recommend Joshua Whitehead enough! I love his fiction and nonfiction, and the SFF collection he edited that Casey mentioned is great, too.

Expand full comment

Hello Laura and other queer readers! I am hoping to use these prompts to, ahem, prompt myself to read some books I marked as ones I was especially excited to read, some of which I own, but I still haven't read yet. So these are maybe less recs than my own TBR, but I hope others will get some ideas!

2. A book of nonfiction by a trans author AND 15. An essay collection

I Hope We Choose Love by Kai Cheng Thom: I own this and I think I've been putting off reading it because then I'll have read all her books and won't have any more to look forward to. I love her writing, so fierce and compassionate.

5. A classic AND 38. A book published in the decade you were born

Macho Sluts by Pat Califia: a book I have owned forever and have never read!! Published in 1988, I was born in 1985.

6. A novel set in a rural place AND 9. A mystery AND 14. A book set on a continent you don’t live on

Dirt Creek by Hayley Scrivenor, a mystery set in a very small town in Australia, told from multiple POVs, including a lesbian detective

11. A nonfiction book about queer parenting AND 26. A book recommended to you by a queer friend or family member

The Natural Mother of the Child by Krys Malcom Belc, nonbinary parent and has been highly recommended to me by a fellow queer parent. TBH I am hoping to read multiple books in 2023 that fit this prompt since I am a newish queer mom.

13. A book with less than 100 ratings on Goodreads

Men I Trust by Tommi Parrish: graphic novel with surreal art, Drew Gregory at Autostraddle gave this a great review and I trust her taste! Plus I have a review copy

16. An SFF book by an Indigenous author AND 39. A Lambda Award finalist or winner

Love After the End edited by Joshua Whitehead, an anthology of queer Indigenous speculative stories that I own but have not read yet! It won the LGBTQ anthology Lambda in 2021.

18. Asexual author AND 19. A YA book without a central romance

A Snake Falls to Earth Darcie Little Badger, YA speculative by a Lipan Apache author, highly anticipated by me for a while! (This could also fit for prompt 16!)

20. A work of graphic nonfiction

Good Talk by Mira Jacobs, a queer parenting graphic memoir I've been meaning to read for ages. What do you all think about listening to the audiobook adaptation though??

22. A novel in verse

The Call-Out by Cat Fitzpatrick: about queer trans women in Brooklyn, own voices, and it's comprised of sonnets! It's supposed to be funny and playful.

23. South Asian author

Roses, in the Mouth of a Lion by Bushra Rehman, a Pakistani American author whose first book Corona I loved. This is set in 80s Queens and being muslim and queer

25. Fat author

Imogen, Obviously by Becky Albertalli: this YA is inspired by her own experiences being surrounded by queer friends and identifying as an ally and finally realizing she was queer (you might remember some nasty speculation online that forced her to come out in bad circumstances)

31. Caribbean author AND 24. A book under 150 pages

Ossuaries OR Thirsty by Dionne Brand: two poetry collections I have owned forever and still have not read!

32. A book of nature or science writing

How Far the Light Reaches by Sabrina Imbler, about queerness and sea creatures!!

33. Weird Queer!

Slug and Other Stories by Megan Milks: this is an exemplar author for this category imho and I've been meaning to read this updated edition of this short story collection. The titular story is about a woman who fucks a giant slug!!

35. A book set in space

The Mimicking of Known Successes by Malka Ann Older: "cozy Holmesian murder mystery and sapphic romance, set on Jupiter" !!

36. An M/F romance novel

Two Wrongs Make a Right by Chloe Liese: bi heroine, opposites attract, I loved this author's holiday romance The Mistletoe Motive and especially liked the autistic and demisexual rep, so I'm excited to read more of her stuff.

37. A work of genre fiction by a trans author

The Two Doctors Górski by Isaac Fellman: I LOVED his other 2022 book Dead Collections so I am dying to read this one, plus it's about a mind-reading grad student

40. African author

The Final Strife by Saara El-Arifi: epic sapphic fantasy inspired by Ghanian and Arabian mythology (that's also her background!)

41. A work of historical fiction set before 1950

Infamous by Lex Croucher, an historical romance set in the Regency period. Supposed to be super queer, playfully anachronistic, and funny.

42. A debut poetry collection

As She Appears by Shelley Wong, "an invitation for queer women of color to arrive in love, exactly as they are" !!!

44. A book published by Arsenal Pulp Press

Hustling Verse edited by Amber Dawn and Justin DuCharme, an anthology of poetry by sex workers!!

45. A book over 500 pages

The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon: sapphic fantasy, 827 pages!! I bought this book like 2 years ago and am still intimidated.

47. Nonbinary protagonist

In the Watchful City by S. Qiouyi Lu, "Asian-inspired mosaic novella that melds the futurism of Lavie Tidhar’s Central Station with the magical wonder of Catherynne M. Valente’s Palimpsest." !!

Expand full comment

Btw Casey, I just saw, browsing what people have added on Storygraph, that Kai Cheng Thom has A NEW BOOK COMING OUT NEXT YEAR! Falling In Love With Being Human: Letters to Lost Souls. "A transformative collection of intimate and lyrical love letters that offer a path toward compassion, forgiveness, and self-acceptance." I love her work, too, and have read it all, so now we both have more to look forward to!

Expand full comment

Oooh what wonderful news!!!

Expand full comment

I also second/highly recommend I Hope We Chose Love, The Natural Mother of the Child, A Snake Falls to Earth and Love After the End!

And I've heard so many great things about How Far the Light Reaches (including a stellar review from Danika at the Lesbrary) so that one is high on my list. So is The Call-Out and The Two Doctors Górski.

And for anyone looking for recs for Caribbean authors, Dionne Brand is amazing! I haven't read either of those poetry collections (adding them to the list) but loved her novel In Another Place, Not Here.

Expand full comment

Re Good Talk by Mira Jacob: The audio is AMAZING! I read it in print and then reread it on audio was totally blown away by the performance. I highly, highly recommend it that way. I also think it's worth reading the print because the art is really interesting, but it works so well on audio, it's one of the books that made me start listening to graphic audio adaptations.

Expand full comment

This is great to know! Maybe I can read them both in tandem.

Expand full comment

OMG CASEY I LOVE THIS! So many on here I have loved, a few on my TBR, and some I've never heard of that I am SO excited to check out because your recs are always so good! Thank you for sharing, I'm so inspired!

Expand full comment

Also I love that you're using the challenge as a way to read books you own/that are on your TBR. I am doing the same thing! I swear I didn't purposely design the prompts this way, but it's possible I was subconsciously thinking of my shelves, because I have something like 70 books that will work for various prompts...

Expand full comment

The one I’m most looking forward to is the one I’ve picked for category #11, Choosing Family: A Memoir of Queer Motherhood and Black Resistance by Francesca T. Royster..but it won’t be out until February. In the meantime, I need recs for pretty much all of the categories!

One I’ve read that I think fits under the “queer protagonist over 50” category is All Adults Here by Emma Straub. The protagonist is a mother and a widow, who falls in love with a woman when her kids are grown. She waits for years to tell them about her relationship...only to discover she’s not the only one in the family who has been keeping a secret.

Expand full comment

And I'm still catching up on all your great newsletter issues, but one that comes to mind that I think might be up your alley is Tell Me How to Be by Neel Patel (for the South Asian author prompt). It's a really beautiful family saga about an Indian American family, mostly a mother and her gay son. Beautifully written, with so many layers and great characters.

Expand full comment

Ooooh. That sounds lovely! I’m putting it on my list right now.

Expand full comment

Oh, I'm so looking forward to hearing what you think of Choosing Family! I read it this fall and absolutely loved it.

And that's good to know about All Adults Here, I've heard of it but didn't really know much of what it was about.

Expand full comment

Thanks for creating this challenge, I'm looking forward to it.

I have two sci-fi recs!

For a novel set in space, I recommend The Space Between Worlds by Micaiah Johnson. It's got time travel, doppelgängers, and a queer relationship that changes as characters jump through different worlds.

My other rec is Light from Uncommon Stars by Ryka Aoki, which I will categorize under Weird Queer! Shizuka Satomi has to capture one more musical prodigy and convince them to sell their soul so she can meet a deal she made with the devil, and she finds the perfect candidate in a young trans runaway who is a talented violinist. Shizuka keeps getting distracted though, by a romantic entanglement with an alien running a donut shop. It's really fun, funny, and weird!

Expand full comment

Uncommon Stars is soooooo good!

Expand full comment

Thanks for these great recs—both books I have read and enjoyed and heartily second!

Expand full comment

I'll start by saying that I'll respond to everyone's comments, though maybe not immediately! I'll also start with a request and a rec: one of the best books I read this year was We Both Laughed In Pleasure by Lou Sullivan. It's a collection of Sullivan's journals from the 1960s through the 1990s. I highly recommend it for the 'A collection of journals or letters' prompt. And because I loved it so much, I'd love to hear if anyone's got suggestions for other books of journals/diaries/letters!

Expand full comment

I will second the Diaries of Anne Lister as enjoyable! I first read a biography of her life (Gentleman Jack) and did enjoy the letters.

I haven't read these, but in looking for ideas, I came across these three:

1. Empty Without You: The Intimate Letters of Eleanor Roosevelt and Lorena Hickok. Apparently many of these were destroyed by both the Roosevelt and HIckok kids because they were so steamy, so these are what survive.

2. Precious and Adored: The Love Letters of Rose Cleveland and Evangeline Simpson Whipple, 1890-1918, edited by Lizzie Ehrenhalt and Tilly Laskey. Apparently Rose Cleveland was the President Grover Cleveland's sister and she had a romance going with another woman, which was set down in their letters to one another. It seems that Whipple was married, and after her second husband died, the two women started living their lives together. :) So Rose Cleveland may have been the first queer woman in the White House.

3. Open Me Carefully: Emily Dickinson's Intimate Letters to Susan Huntington Dickinson. I don't know much about Emily Dickinson, but it makes absolute sense to me that she was queer. This book was marked as LGBTQIA on a lot of sites, including Storygraph, but I don't know for sure.

I also had a professor in college who was a Woolf scholar and she said that Woolf and Vita Sackville-West's letters were very interesting to read, but I also have not read those myself. Hope all these help!

Expand full comment

I read Open Me Carefully a few years ago. It’s definitely LGBTQIA. Also definitely worth a read.

Expand full comment

This is great! So many 20th century sapphics! There's actually quite a few I see that people have added on Storygraph, including these three. I had the Woolf letters and the ones between Eleanor Roosevelt and Lorena Hickok on my radar, but I didn't know about Rose Cleveland.

Expand full comment

I read the Diaries of Anne Lister many years ago and found them so fascinating! There was a delightful juxtaposition of her every day 18th century life details (I'm a nerd, I found those interesting) and then like, her lesbian drama which was incredible.

Expand full comment

Oh, thanks for this! I am definitely here for 18th century lesbian drama!

Expand full comment